Sonny Rollins on "Just Friends"
Sonny Meets Hawk! (1963) was too far from my expectations for me to appreciate it when I first checked it out a couple years ago. I picked up the record to hear Sonny, rather than Coleman Hawkins, but the Sonny on this record doesn't play the elegant, more easily vocabularized lines found on Saxophone Colossus (1956) or Way Out West (1957). Pat Metheny, in Ben Ratliff's excellent The Jazz Ear , has an interesting take on Sonny's playing on this record: "He was a young guy at the time," Metheny marveled, listening to Rollins's emphatic, darting lines in "All the Things You Are," harmonically at odds with Hawkins's, on the opening chorus. "That feeling is such a great feeling—like 'I can play anything , and it's all good.' Not to analyze it, but Hawk was kind of like his father. And it's like Sonny's saying, 'yeah, but ...'" I'd also add that Sonny's playing on this record is as far from 'acad...